October had only one story. E8. There's a lot of writing here so if you'd rather not indulge, just skip to the bottom of this post for the links.
One more time before I get to my rambling; In the 20+ years I've been obsessed with this band I have never had direct contact with any of them, and I have no insider knowledge. For the most part Editors do a great job of being a closed-circuit, as they should. Whatever I say here are just speculative theories based on what we've learned from press interviews over the years. I could, and may well be, way off in my assumptions.
Now that Surface Echo and Sound is out here in the world, we can finally assess it on its own terms, and just where it fits in the lineage of Editors' back catalogue. This won't be a review, because every person listening to the record will have their own personal take based on where they meet it, and what they brought with them when they did. This one is mine.
If you've been here for a while, you already know what I'm about to say. Editors' singular curse and blessing is that they are most effective at conveying their message and sound in a live form. It's always been that way, and so each successive record carries an accompanying guidance amongst fans; "Wait until you hear it live before making a final decision on how you feel about it". It still applies.
Surface Echo and Sound is an "album" in the classic sense of the world, where it feels like a collection of songs that have been arranged to take the listener on a journey from point A to point B. I also feel that it accurately captures Editors current state in terms of their development as a group. All the bands that I revere have that ability, where their records become diary entries which freeze a moment and preserve it forever. If they are successful at it, as a listener you can revisit them later on and remember exactly what was happening to produce those songs.
For me, Rescue is the central focus of this record for a very specific reason; I would suggest that the steps they chose to build this album may very well have saved them as a band, a form of self-rescue. It is my belief that, had they approached the construction of Surface Echo and Sound in the same way they did EBM, they may not have lasted beyond the promotional cycle they're about to undertake. If they'd made it that far at all.
"And if we lose hope, I wouldn't lose my faith in you..."
Here are two points to stick a pin in and return to later.
There's a theory that musicians are drawn to their chosen instrument with a reward in mind, one that they may not even been aware of. There's a specific, personal gratification derived from mastering and utilising that object. As a for instance, maybe Ed enjoys the physicality of hitting objects to keep a tempo, or Justin get's his psychic fill from constructing melodies from six empty strings. The problems arise when you reduce or even remove access to that fulfilment, possibly through a change in the way you operate as a musician. For example, programming a drum machine is probably never going to have the same satisfaction as throwing your body into battering a drum kit. Just to complicate matters further, everyone in any band will have their own unique wants and needs in that respect, it's essential that there's a symmetry among all the players. It's a meticulous balancing act that, if executed correctly, can lead to point number 2.
The second point is that natural chemistry in bands is a verifiable phenomenon. There have been times when the departure or addition of even a single member of a band can alter its trajectory entirely. Terry Bickers leaving the House of Love changed their sound, even though he wasn't the primary songwriter in that band. Vince Clarke took most of the pop sensibilities with him when he left Depeche Mode, which would see the group who did Just Can't Get Enough go on to create songs with much darker tones like Stripped, or Barrel of a Gun.

Historically, Editors extinction events seem to become more likely the further they drift from their original interconnection, or when they separate into factions. Once that cohesiveness becomes diminished it seems to put them on a course to potential self-destruction. Take In This Light... as an example. Prior to that, they had made two classic "as a band" albums with guitars bass and drums. If I listen to either of those records I'm able to mentally picture the people playing what I'm hearing. Russell on the bass, Ed on the drums, Chris on guitar and Tom singing and playing. I can hear it but also see it. Their third record saw them experiment with all new instruments and move well beyond their own comfort zone as a collective. It's an honourable tradition of not wanting to repeat yourselves as artists, and it shook everything up. A necessary test to see what they were capable of. The need to innovate and take your songwriting somewhere new whilst allowing the chemistry that it originates from to remain undiluted.
What is interesting is that when I play some of the material on In This Light... now, I close my eyes and I can't see the band playing their parts. I'm not sure who is doing what. I know that there are places online where you can check out old Editors live videos from that time (cough), and so you can actually take a look and confirm who was doing what when the music is performed. What I'm talking about is that practice of putting some headphones on, closing your eyes ad taking the trip with an album or song. I should add that In This Light... is my favourite Editors record for all the reasons I just mentioned, but that innovation came at a cost.
When they actually began working on album 4, there were indicators that the band were going to further explore the electronic sounds they were working with on In This Light.... This was a statement made by Tom in late 2010 as part of the release of the Unedited box set.
Here's what it says if you're unable to see the photo:-
"Another year races towards its end and Editors are a hive of activity. It won't be long until we're together again as a band rehearsing the first ideas for album 4. Obviously it's a big task but we have songs now and the wheels are well and truly in motion. The idea is to record in stages over 2011 but first things must come first and we need to get into a room together and play, see where the ideas take us. These are exciting times and we're all looking forward to taking our relationship with Mr Flood further... first rehearsals start in a matter of days."
You can see they had a plan and, ironically, that plan was primarily to get into a room and just play. Then the relationship with Chris reached a point of collapse, and the ways of working that had produced three albums suddenly stopped being productive. We had read stories of circumstances deteriorating to the point of there being rehearsal sessions via Skype.
Editors' fourth album, The Weight of Your Love seems to have been a return to the very methodology that produced the first two records. Gone was the exploration of electronica, and instead there was an embrace of the comfort derived from familiarity. With Elliott and Justin on board they returned to the dynamic of being a group of musicians playing their instruments, connecting with each other on a creative level. Eye contact and synergy. From the opening drum beat of The Weight, I can see the songs being played again. Although The Weight of Your Love has, in my opinion, a mild case of identity confusion, I do believe that the way it was assembled saved them from splitting up.
As a record, I think it's that important.
That connectivity and equal contribution rejuvenated the chemistry that had dissipated after In This Light... was finished. It is my opinion, that Surface Echo and Sound has the same redemptive power that The Weight of Your Love did, only this time it's more assured.
This isn't a "let's bash Blanck Mass" post. I really like EBM, and he is responsible for what would become one of my favourite Editors songs in Barricades. I do feel, however, that the division of labour after his addition during the making of EBM may have inadvertently been setting up a potential Editors extinction event down the line. In the same way that the variations from normal working practices ended up almost derailing Editors entirely post-In This Light...
Remember the points I made earlier that I said to stick a pin in? That band chemistry is important,as well as the personal gratification an artist gets from their chosen instrument? EBM seems to have been a fracture of those two things at once. Tom has said that he didn't have as much to do during the writing of EBM as he had with previous records, which is crazy given his status as primary songwriter. There were also reports of Ed not actually being required for some of the drum parts because Ben was doing them. How do you reconcile being a contributing member of a band if you are simultaneously told your services aren't required? There seems to have been an extremely severe drift from standard operating procedures which is, of course, the very basis for trying to push boundaries and create something novel. Rearranging things is the point yet, as with In This Light..., it can wreak interpersonal havoc.
When it was announced that Blanck Mass was too busy to return for album 8, I wondered if it would force them back into a room in the same way The Weight of Your Love did. That everyone would reconnect and restore the balance that had been tilted off the equilibrium that has given us so much creativity over the years. I do think it's interesting that the song Much Love originates as a puzzle from a time when they were disconnected as a group in 2011. It was only finally "solved" when they were at their most interconnected during 2026. Fifteen years later. Was it luck, or maybe chemistry and an equality of contribution at work?
To further illustrate the fragile complexities of interpersonal chemistry, it is my belief that in the addition of Nic Willes to the band has changed them for the better. I think you'll see the confirmation of that when they tour next year. He makes Editors more.
I would also suggest that recording of his solo record, and the subsequent tour Tom did with Nic in support of it may have brought him back to the simple joy of just playing music to people. The electricity you get from picking up an instrument, the very instrument that most Editors songs begin life on, and just playing it to see where it take you. That freedom and re-acquaintance with something that was once more familiar, which it sounds like he rolled back into the E8 session with. I will say that my brain is still is a slight state of confusion because when I listen to the studio take of Rescue, I see Nic playing the mandolin even though he wasn't part of the recording process.
The TL:DR version is that I think Surface Echo and Sound saved Editors as a band. It sounds like they managed to locate the functioning components that got them 7 albums in and taught themselves how to harness it again for album 8. They sound like a group, one where everybody's metaphorical needs are being met.
As you would expect, given the event that dominated October in Editors' fandom, there was a substantial collection of videos and photos from this month. All of which are available in the zip file below. There was also a very important show in Colombia, and you can check out that entire gig using
this link.
Enjoy the stuff ;)
Editors Instagram - October 2026
For all of Editors' previous Instagram posts, go here.
brought to you with lots and lots of lemming-love :) x